Abstract
Neurological evidence is increasingly used in criminal cases to argue that a defendant is less responsible for their behaviour, is not competent to stand trial or should receive a reduced punishment for the crime. Unfortunately, neurologists are rarely involved in such cases despite having the expertise to help to inform these decisions in court. In this Perspective, we advocate for the development of ‘forensic neurology’, a subspecialty of neurology focused on using neurological clinical and scientific expertise to address legal questions for the criminal justice system. We review literature suggesting that the incidence of criminal behaviour is higher in people with certain neurological disorders than the general public and that undiagnosed neurological abnormalities are common in people who commit crimes. We discuss the need for forensic neurologists in criminal cases to provide an opinion on what neurological diagnoses are present, the resulting symptoms and ultimately whether the symptoms affect legal determinations such as criminal responsibility or competency.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Access Nature and 54 other Nature Portfolio journals
Get Nature+, our best-value online-access subscription
$29.99 / 30 days
cancel any time
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 12 print issues and online access
$209.00 per year
only $17.42 per issue
Buy this article
- Purchase on Springer Link
- Instant access to full article PDF
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Denno, D. W. How experts have dominated the neuroscience narrative in criminal cases for twelve decades: a warning for the future. William Mary Law Rev. 63, 1215–1288 (2022).
Greely, H. T. & Farahany, N. A. Neuroscience and the criminal justice system. Annu. Rev. Criminol. 2, 451–471 (2019).
Lewis, D. O., Pincus, J. H., Feldman, M., Jackson, L. & Bard, B. Psychiatric, neurological, and psychoeducational characteristics of 15 death row inmates in the United States. Am. J. Psychiatry 143, 838–845 (1986).
Blake, P. Y., Pincus, J. H. & Buckner, C. Neurologic abnormalities in murderers. Neurology 45, 1641–1647 (1995).
Lewis, D. O., Shanok, S. S., Pincus, J. H. & Glaser, G. H. Violent juvenile delinquents: psychiatric, neurological, psychological, and abuse factors. J. Am. Acad. Child Psychiatry 18, 307–319 (1979).
Lewis, D. O. et al. Neuropsychiatric, psychoeducational, and family characteristics of 14 juveniles condemned to death in the United States. Am. J. Psychiatry 145, 584–589 (1988).
Moriarty, J. C. & Langleben, D. D. Who speaks for neuroscience? Neuroimaging evidence and courtroom expertise. Case West. Reserve Law Rev. 68, 783–804 (2018).
Blumber, J. M. et al. Report to the Governor: Medical Aspects Charles J. Whitman Catastrophe, https://web.archive.org/web/20171215181220/http://alt.cimedia.com/statesman/specialreports/whitman/findings.pdf (1966).
Baskin, J. H., Edersheim, J. G. & Price, B. H. Is a picture worth a thousand words? Am. J. Law Med. 33, 239–269 (2007).
Grafman, J. et al. Frontal lobe injuries, violence, and aggression: a report of the Vietnam Head Injury Study. Neurology 46, 1231–1238 (1996).
Fazel, S., Lichtenstein, P., Grann, M. & Långström, N. Risk of violent crime in individuals with epilepsy and traumatic brain injury: a 35-year Swedish population study. PLoS Med. 8, e1001150 (2011).
Timonen, M. et al. The association of preceding traumatic brain injury with mental disorders, alcoholism and criminality: the Northern Finland 1966 Birth Cohort Study. Psychiatry Res. 113, 217–226 (2002).
Darby, R. R. Neuroimaging abnormalities in neurological patients with criminal behavior. Curr. Neurol. Neurosci. Rep. 18, 47 (2018).
Elbogen, E. B., Wolfe, J. R., Cueva, M., Sullivan, C. & Johnson, J. Longitudinal predictors of criminal arrest after traumatic brain injury: results from the traumatic brain injury model system national database. J. Head Trauma Rehabil. 30, E3–E13 (2015).
Kim, E. et al. Neuropsychiatric complications of traumatic brain injury: a critical review of the literature (a report by the ANPA Committee on Research). J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 19, 106–127 (2007).
Wortzel, H. S. Advanced neuroimaging and mild traumatic brain injury litigation, revisited. J. Am. Acad. Psychiatry Law 50, 336–341 (2022).
Pardini, M. et al. Prefrontal cortex lesions and MAO-A modulate aggression in penetrating traumatic brain injury. Neurology 76, 1038–1045 (2011).
Anderson, S. W., Bechara, A., Damasio, H., Tranel, D. & Damasio, A. R. Impairment of social and moral behavior related to early damage in human prefrontal cortex. Nat. Neurosci. 2, 1032–1037 (1999).
Taber-Thomas, B. C. et al. Arrested development: early prefrontal lesions impair the maturation of moral judgement. Brain 137, 1254–1261 (2014).
Anderson, S. W., Barrash, J., Bechara, A. & Tranel, D. Impairments of emotion and real-world complex behavior following childhood- or adult-onset damage to ventromedial prefrontal cortex. J. Int. Neuropsychol. Soc. 12, 224–235 (2006).
Anderson, S. W., Damasio, H. & Tranel, D. Neuropsychological impairments associated with lesions caused by tumor or stroke. Arch. Neurol. 47, 397–405 (1990).
Glenn, A. L. & Raine, A. Neurocriminology: implications for the punishment, prediction and prevention of criminal behaviour. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 15, 54–63 (2013).
Darby, R. R., Horn, A., Cushman, F. & Fox, M. D. Lesion network localization of criminal behavior. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 115, 601–606 (2018).
Darby, R. R. & Caplan, D. “Cat-gras” delusion: a unique misidentification syndrome and a novel explanation. Neurocase 22, 251–256 (2016).
Darby, R. & Prasad, S. Lesion-related delusional misidentification syndromes: a comprehensive review of reported cases. J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 28, 217–222 (2016).
Darby, R. R., Laganiere, S., Pascual-Leone, A., Prasad, S. & Fox, M. D. Finding the imposter: brain connectivity of lesions causing delusional misidentifications. Brain 140, 497–507 (2017).
Darby, R. R. A network-based response to the two-factor theory of delusion formation. Cogn. Neuropsychiatry 24, 178–182 (2019).
Liljegren, M. et al. Criminal behavior in frontotemporal dementia and Alzheimer disease. JAMA Neurol. 72, 295–300 (2015).
Phan, T. X. et al. Measuring antisocial behaviors in behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia with a novel informant-based questionnaire. J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 35, 374–384 (2023).
Diehl-Schmid, J., Perneczky, R., Koch, J., Nedopil, N. & Kurz, A. Guilty by suspicion? Criminal behavior in frontotemporal lobar degeneration. Cogn. Behav. Neurol. 26, 73–77 (2013).
Miller, B. L., Darby, A., Benson, D. F., Cummings, J. L. & Miller, M. H. Aggressive, socially disruptive and antisocial behaviour associated with fronto-temporal dementia. Br. J. Psychiatry 170, 150–154 (1997).
Mendez, M. F., Chen, A. K., Shapira, J. S. & Miller, B. L. Acquired sociopathy and frontotemporal dementia. Dement. Geriatr. Cogn. Disord. 20, 99–104 (2005).
Shinagawa, S. et al. Violation of laws in frontotemporal dementia: a multicenter study in Japan. J. Alzheimers Dis. 57, 1221–1227 (2017).
Mendez, M. F., Anderson, E. & Shapira, J. S. An investigation of moral judgement in frontotemporal dementia. Cogn. Behav. Neurol. 18, 193–197 (2005).
Ducharme, S., Price, B. H., Larvie, M., Dougherty, D. D. & Dickerson, B. C. Clinical approach to the differential diagnosis between behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia and primary psychiatric disorders. Am. J. Psychiatry 172, 827–837 (2015).
Darby, R. R., Edersheim, J. & Price, B. H. What patients with behavioral-variant frontotemporal dementia can teach us about moral responsibility. AJOB Neurosci. 7, 193–201 (2016).
Darby, W. C. et al. in Ethics and Clinical Neuroinnovation (ed. Weiss Roberts, L.) 173–193 (Springer International, 2023).
Darby, R. R. Network localization of antisocial behavior in neurological patients: evidence and implications. Handb. Clin. Neurol. 197, 45–54 (2023).
McDonell, K. E. et al. Risk-taking behaviors in Huntington’s disease. J. Huntingt. Dis. 9, 359–369 (2020).
McDonell, K. E. et al. Medicolegal aspects of huntington disease. J. Am. Acad. Psychiatry Law 49, 565–571 (2021).
Darby, R. R. & Dickerson, B. C. Dementia, decision making, and capacity. Harv. Rev. Psychiatry 25, 270–278 (2017).
Dawson, A. et al. Capacity, control and responsibility in Parkinson’s disease patients with impulse control disorders: views of neurological and psychiatric experts. Int. J. Law Psychiatry 65, 101343 (2019).
Boeve, B. F. et al. Pathophysiology of REM sleep behaviour disorder and relevance to neurodegenerative disease. Brain 130, 2770–2788 (2007).
Siclari, F. et al. Violence in sleep. Brain 133, 3494–3509 (2010).
Castelnovo, A., Lopez, R., Proserpio, P., Nobili, L. & Dauvilliers, Y. NREM sleep parasomnias as disorders of sleep-state dissociation. Nat. Rev. Neurol. 14, 470–481 (2018).
Stallman, H. M. & Kohler, M. Prevalence of sleepwalking: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 11, e0164769 (2016).
Cramer Bornemann, M. A., Schenck, C. H. & Mahowald, M. W. A review of sleep-related violence: the demographics of sleep forensics referrals to a single center. Chest 155, 1059–1066 (2019).
Ingravallo, F. et al. Sleep-related violence and sexual behavior in sleep: a systematic review of medical-legal case reports. J. Clin. Sleep Med. 10, 927–935 (2014).
Pressman, M. R. Factors that predispose, prime and precipitate NREM parasomnias in adults: clinical and forensic implications. Sleep Med. Rev. 11, 5–30 (2007).
Pressman, M. R., Mahowald, M. W., Schenck, C. H. & Bornemann, M. C. Alcohol-induced sleepwalking or confusional arousal as a defense to criminal behavior: a review of scientific evidence, methods and forensic considerations. J. Sleep Res. 16, 198–212 (2007).
American Academy of Sleep Medicine. International Classification of Sleep Disorders 3rd edn (American Academy of Sleep Medicine, 2014).
Murdoch, D. & Ross, D. Alcohol and crimes of violence: present issues. Subst. Use Misuse 25, 1065–1081 (1990).
Haggård-Grann, U., Hallqvist, J., Långström, N. & Möller, J. The role of alcohol and drugs in triggering criminal violence: a case-crossover study. Addiction 101, 100–108 (2006).
Mahowald, M. W. & Schenck, C. H. NREM sleep parasomnias. Neurol. Clin. 14, 675–696 (1996).
Borum, R. & Appelbaum, K. L. Epilepsy, aggression, and criminal responsibility. Psychiatr. Serv. 47, 762–763 (1996).
Treiman, D. M. Epilepsy and violence: medical and legal issues. Epilepsia 27, S77–S104 (1986).
Reuber, M. & Mackay, R. D. Epileptic automatisms in the criminal courts: 13 cases tried in England and Wales between 1975 and 2001. Epilepsia 49, 138–145 (2008).
Saleh, C., Reuber, M. & Beyenburg, S. Epileptic seizures and criminal acts: is there a relationship? Epilepsy Behav. 97, 15–21 (2019).
Fisher, R. S. & Engel, J. J. Definition of the postictal state: when does it start and end? Epilepsy Behav. 19, 100–104 (2010).
Kanemoto, K., Tadokoro, Y. & Oshima, T. Violence and postictal psychosis: a comparison of postictal psychosis, interictal psychosis, and postictal confusion. Epilepsy Behav. 19, 162–166 (2010).
Fazel, S., Philipson, J., Gardiner, L., Merritt, R. & Grann, M. Neurological disorders and violence: a systematic review and meta-analysis with a focus on epilepsy and traumatic brain injury. J. Neurol. 256, 1591–1602 (2009).
Pandya, N. S., Vrbancic, M., Ladino, L. D. & Téllez-Zenteno, J. F. Epilepsy and homicide. Neuropsychiatr. Dis. Treat. 9, 667–673 (2013).
Kim, J.-M. et al. Characteristics of epilepsy patients who committed violent crimes: report from the National Forensic Hospital. J. Epilepsy Res. 1, 13–18 (2011).
Schalock, R. L., Luckasson, R. & Tassé, M. J. An overview of intellectual disability: definition, diagnosis, classification, and systems of supports (12th ed.). Am. J. Intellect. Dev. Disabil. 126, 439–442 (2021).
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-5-TR (American Psychiatric Association, 2022).
Nixon, M., Thomas, S. D. M., Daffern, M. & Ogloff, J. R. P. Estimating the risk of crime and victimisation in people with intellectual disability: a data-linkage study. Soc. Psychiatry Psychiatr. Epidemiol. 52, 617–626 (2017).
Bonnie, R. J. The American Psychiatric Association’s resource document on mental retardation and capital sentencing: implementing Atkins v. Virginia. J. Am. Acad. Psychiatry Law 32, 304–308 (2004).
Berryessa, C. M. Defendants with autism spectrum disorder in criminal court: a judges’ toolkit. Drexel Law Rev. 13, 841–868 (2021).
Murrie, D. C., Warren, J. I., Kristiansson, M. & Dietz, P. E. Asperger’s syndrome in forensic settings. Int. J. Forensic Ment. Health 1, 59–70 (2002).
Raine, A. The Anatomy of Violence: the Biological Roots of Crime 1st edn (Pantheon Books, 2013).
Raine, A., Buchsbaum, M. & Lacasse, L. Brain abnormalities in murderers indicated by positron emission tomography. Biol. Psychiatry 42, 495–508 (1997).
Schiltz, K., Witzel, J. G., Bausch-Hölterhoff, J. & Bogerts, B. High prevalence of brain pathology in violent prisoners: a qualitative CT and MRI scan study. Eur. Arch. Psychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 263, 607–616 (2013).
Witzel, J. G., Bogerts, B. & Schiltz, K. Increased frequency of brain pathology in inmates of a high — security forensic institution: a qualitative CT and MRI scan study. Eur. Arch. Psychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 266, 533–541 (2016).
Farrer, T. J. & Hedges, D. W. Prevalence of traumatic brain injury in incarcerated groups compared to the general population: a meta-analysis. Prog. Neuropsychopharmacol. Biol. Psychiatry 35, 390–394 (2011).
Durand, E. et al. History of traumatic brain injury in prison populations: a systematic review. Ann. Phys. Rehabil. Med. 60, 95–101 (2017).
Edersheim, J. G., Brendel, R. W. & Price, B. H. in Neuroimaging in Forensic Psychiatry: From the Clinic to the Courtroom (ed. Simpson, J. R.) 163–193 (John Wiley & Sons, 2012).
Brower, M. C. & Price, B. H. Neuropsychiatry of frontal lobe dysfunction in violent and criminal behaviour: a critical review. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 71, 720–726 (2001).
Chialant, D., Edersheim, J. & Price, B. H. The dialectic between empathy and violence: an opportunity for intervention? J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 28, 273–285 (2016).
Daffner, K. R. et al. Improving clinical cognitive testing: report of the AAN Behavioral Neurology Section Workgroup. Neurology 85, 910–918 (2015).
Szczepanski, S. M. & Knight, R. T. Insights into human behavior from lesions to the prefrontal cortex. Neuron 83, 1002–1018 (2014).
Fox, M. D. Localizing symptoms to brain networks using the human connectome. N. Engl. J. Med. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMra1706158 (2018).
Darby, R. R., Joutsa, J. & Fox, M. D. Network localization of heterogeneous neuroimaging findings. Brain 142, 70–79 (2019).
Boes, A. D. et al. Network localization of neurological symptoms from focal brain lesions. Brain 138, 3061–3075 (2015).
Darby, R. R. & Fox, M. D. Reply: capgras syndrome: neuroanatomical assessment of brain MRI findings in an adolescent patient. Brain 140, e44 (2017).
Tetreault, A. M. et al. Network localization of clinical, cognitive, and neuropsychiatric symptoms in Alzheimer’s disease. Brain 143, 1249–1260 (2020).
Darby, R. R., Joutsa, J. & Fox, M. D. Lesion network localization of free will. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 115, 10792–10797 (2018).
Tetreault, A. M. et al. Network localization of alien limb in patients with corticobasal syndrome. Ann. Neurol. 88, 1118–1131 (2020).
Darby, R. R. & Pascual-Leone, A. Moral enhancement using non-invasive brain stimulation. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 11, 77 (2017).
Heilbronner, R. L. American Academy of Clinical Neuropsychology (AACN) practice guidelines for neuropsychological assessment and consultation. Clin. Neuropsychol. 21, 209–231 (2007).
Smith, G. et al. Education and training in clinical neuropsychology: recent developments and documents from the clinical neuropsychology synarchy. Arch. Clin. Neuropsychol. 34, 418–431 (2019).
Donders, J. The incremental value of neuropsychological assessment: a critical review. Clin. Neuropsychol. 34, 56–87 (2020).
Sweet, J. J. et al. Forensic neuropsychology: history and current status. Clin. Neuropsychol. 37, 459–474 (2023).
Larsson, E.-M. & Wikström, J. Overview of neuroradiology. Handb. Clin. Neurol. 145, 579–599 (2017).
Ross, D. E., Ochs, A. L., Seabaugh, J. M., Shrader, C. R. & Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative. Man versus machine: comparison of radiologists’ interpretations and NeuroQuant® volumetric analyses of brain MRIs in patients with traumatic brain injury. J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 25, 32–39 (2013).
Meltzer, C. C. et al. Guidelines for the ethical use of neuroimages in medical testimony: report of a multidisciplinary consensus conference. Am. J. Neuroradiol. 35, 632–637 (2014).
Sfera, A., Osorio, C., Gradini, R. & Price, A. Neurodegeneration behind bars: from molecules to jurisprudence. Front. Psychiatry 5, 115 (2014).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
R.R.D. conceptualized the article. All authors researched data for the article. All authors contributed substantially to discussion of the content. R.R.D. wrote the article. All authors reviewed and/or edited the manuscript before submission.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
All authors have worked as paid expert witnesses in criminal cases.
Peer review
Peer review information
Nature Reviews Neurology thanks Bruce Price, who co-reviewed with Shyam Akula; Jane Moriarty; and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Related links
Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) fellowship: https://www.aapl.org/fellowship
American Academy of Psychiatry and Law: https://www.aapl.org/updating.htm?was=$1Forensic%20Neuropsychiatry.pdf
American Neuropsychiatric Association: https://anpaonline.org/SIGs
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Darby, R.R., Considine, C., Weinstock, R. et al. Forensic neurology: a distinct subspecialty at the intersection of neurology, neuroscience and law. Nat Rev Neurol 20, 183–193 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41582-023-00920-0
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41582-023-00920-0